The Government has announced plans to scrap the leasehold system in England and Wales and move to commonhold as the default tenure for new flats, according to a report by the BBC today.
The announcement has been described as the most significant reform to residential property ownership in decades. But what does it actually mean in practice, and what happens next?
What did the BBC report?
The BBC reports that the Government intends to bring the leasehold system to an end and replace it with commonhold, a model already used in Scotland and in many other countries, including Australia, the US and much of continental Europe.
Under commonhold, flat owners collectively own the freehold of their building and manage it together, rather than holding a lease from a separate freeholder.
The report follows more than 1,000 leaseholders contacting the BBC over the past two years with concerns about ground rent, service charges, and the cost of extending a lease.
There are currently around 5 million leasehold homes in England and Wales.
Why has leasehold come under criticism?
Leaseholders own the right to occupy their property for a set term under a lease, but the freeholder retains ownership of the building and land. In practice, many leaseholders have faced:
- Ground rent that increases over time, in some cases doubling every 10 years
- Service charges that can be difficult to challenge
- Fees for permission to make alterations, keep a pet, or carry out improvements
- Significant costs to extend a lease as the term shortens, which can affect saleability and mortgageability
Ground rent was abolished for most new residential leases in 2022, but it remains an issue for many existing leaseholders.
What is commonhold?
Commonhold has been available in England and Wales since 2002, but has rarely been used.
In a commonhold building, owners own their flat outright and jointly own the common parts through a commonhold association. There is no external freeholder and no ground rent.
Supporters argue this gives homeowners greater control and removes the imbalance inherent in the leaseholder-freeholder relationship.
What about existing leaseholders?
This is the key question.
The Government has indicated that existing leaseholders will benefit from a cap on ground rent, expected to come into force in 2028, alongside reforms to make lease extensions cheaper and simpler.
However, the details of how existing leaseholders will be able to move to commonhold, or otherwise benefit from the reforms, have not yet been published. A draft Bill is expected to provide further clarity.
What about freeholders and managing agents?
It is important to note that not all freeholders and managing agents operate unfairly. Many provide essential services for large and complex buildings, including insurance, repairs, health and safety compliance, and management of communal areas.
New systems will need to ensure buildings continue to be properly managed and funded, and that lenders, developers and managing agents have confidence in the new framework.
The success of commonhold will depend on whether lenders are willing to lend on commonhold properties at scale – something that has limited take-up to date.
What happens next?
The Government is expected to publish a draft Bill setting out the detail of the reforms. This will be scrutinised by Parliament and is likely to be subject to significant debate.
As property solicitors, we will be monitoring the proposals closely, particularly in relation to:
- The position of existing leaseholders
- The proposed cap on ground rent
- The practical framework for commonhold and building management
- Transitional arrangements for developments already in progress
What should leaseholders do now?
If you are a leaseholder, there is no need to take immediate action based on a recent announcement alone. The current law remains in force until new legislation is passed.
If you are considering buying, selling, or extending a lease, it is advisable to seek legal advice on your specific position, as your options may change once the reforms are enacted.
For general guidance on your lease, please contact Sarita Ghere, Partner and Co-Head of our property team at sg@branchaustinmccormick.com.